top of page
Writer's pictureseriouslysarahsauc

Any Cookie will do really-Cookie Pie Crust Recipe

Updated: Jul 6, 2021

Mr. Wilson loves pie, he loves apple pie, he loves pumpkin pie, banana pudding pie there are very few pies that Mr. Wilson won’t try but he isn’t always a fan of the crust on pies.

Too Flaky, Too soft, Too crunchy so I try to do most of the pies in a graham cracker pie crust and not going to lie often it is a store bought graham cracker pie crust because….well convenience.



This thanksgiving Mr. Wilson requested pumpkin pie and banana pudding pie but he wanted them in a graham cracker crust- Turns out using a store bought pie crust for the pumpkin pie wasn’t going to work because they get a little burnt. So I thought about the different ways to accomplish this without losing any flavor and I decided what if I make my own and sorta do a par baking so the crust will finish baking once the pumpkin is added.

So while others have visions of sugar-plums dancing in their heads I had visions of pie crusts dancing in mine, a simple graham cracker pie crust can really be recreated with any cookie that wasn’t filled with chocolate chips or caramel bits.


My first trial (when the photos were taken) I used a cinnamon sugar mixture instead of the regular granulated sugar and the taste was what I wanted but it created a more chewy crust and a much darker crust than I intended so on the next go around I used plain sugar and the crusts had a more traditional pie crust color and a more graham cracker style crust, but both crusts were really good.

As Always Remember to Wash Your Hands, Wear A mask


Simple Any Cookie Pie Crust


70 Nilla wafers/ Oreo Cookies/ Shortbread cookies/ graham crackers

¼ cup granulated sugar

1/3 cup melted butter


Preheat oven to 350- Lightly spray pie plate with cooking spray and set aside


Place cookies in food processor and pulse until only the crumbs remain (You can also do this by hand with a Ziploc baggie)


Transfer cookie crumbs to a medium size bowl stir in sugar and melted butter


Once the mixture is combined well Press the crumbs firmly into the pie plate and up the sides ( I added Cinnamon to this crust which is why the crust is a bit darker)



Bake for 10 minutes at or until edges are starting to brown.

Allow to completely cool on a wire rack before filling




Comments


bottom of page